Crambe (Crambe Hispanica Subsp. Abyssinica) Grains Mycobiota and Natural Occurrence of Aflatoxins, Ochratoxin A, Fumonisin B1 and Zearalenone

*Corresponding author: Carlos Alberto da Rocha Rosa*


Rosetto CAV, de Oliveira AA, Keller LAM, Cavaglieri LR, Rodrigues E, da Rocha Rosa CA. Crambe (Crambe hispanica subsp. Abyssinica) grains mycobiota and natural occurrence of aflatoxins, ochratoxin A, fumonisin B1 and zearalenone. Adv Food Technol Nutr Sci Open J. 2016; 2(1): 32-37. doi: 10.17140/AFTNSOJ-2-128


©2016 da Rocha Rosa CA. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

Full-Text PDF:

original research


Crambe grains are a new feed with high concentrations of proteins and fibers. As there is no control during the pre-harvesting or post-harvesting stages of production other grains, crambe may be contaminated by fungi. Fungal overgrowth may lead to mycotoxins production and nutritional properties decrease of the grains. The aim of this study was to analyze the occurrence of fungi and mycotoxins according to pre-harvesting management. Fungal concentration was higher than that recommended by international regulations (3.4×106 to 1.3×104 CFU.g-1), suggesting that management in pre-harvesting stages of crambe grains production may expose the animals that will feed on these grains to the risk of contamination by fungal toxins. More studies are required about quality of crambe grains, because may be strongly affected by the exposition to variable environmental conditions. But, considering low mycotoxin incidence and levels founded, the crambe proves to be a safe food to be exploited for animal nutrition.


Afs: Aflatoxins; OTA: Ochratoxin A; ZEA: Zearalenone; UFRRJ: Universidade Federal Rural do Rio de Janeiro; DRBC: Dichloran, Rose-Bengal Chloramphenicol; HPLC: High-Performance Liquid Chromatography; AOAC: Association of Official Analytical Chemists; LSD: Least Significant Difference; ANOVA: Analysis of variance


Crambe hispanica subsp. abyssinica or Crambe abyssinica is an oleaginous subspecies belonging to Brassicaceae family plant, original from Mediterranean region. Crambe was introduced in Brazil for the production of biodiesel and to be used as forage. The inclusion of crambe seeds was expected to correct the dry matter content and also increase the crude protein content of the silage (containing 37% of oil, 21% proteins, 13% fibers, magnesium, potassium and other minerals),1 reducing diet costs and potential environmental impacts from the disposal of this material on the environment.2 But, the presence of glycosylates and the mycotoxins limit the use of crambe in ruminant diets should be limited to 4%.3 The US guideline was only founded limiting the rational use.4

As happens with other cultures, crambe may be contaminated by fungi, which may jeopardize physical and nutritional features of the plant and produce mycotoxins, dangerous for human and animal health. Among mycotoxins, special attention must be paid to aflatoxins (AFs) and ochratoxin A (OTA), produced respectively by fungi of the genus Aspergillus, section. Flavi, such as Aspergillus flavus and A. parasiticus and by fungi of the genus Penicillum.5 According to the Brazilian regulation, maximum concentration of total AFs in grains is 50 ppb.6

Monitoring of grains during pre-harvest and postharvest stages is important to avoid undesirable fungal overgrowth and mycotoxins productions. During post-harvest stage, the inspection of storage conditions is crucial at this stage, as the same important, may be impossible disregards geographic localization of cultures and production systems.7 Contamination of seeds by mycotoxins producing fungi is mainly associated to the relation between the plant and its endophytic mycobiota and to other biological interactions.8 The main interaction that may lead to a contamination of crambe can be those with insects, with the soil,9 farming practices,10 adverse meteorological conditions during the final stage of grains ripening or grains genotype.11Mycotoxins of Fusarium species have been found to cause major damage, especially in cereals, and could frequently be associated with pre-harvest cereal contamination. The importance of climatic and meteorological assessment during cultivation to assess contamination risks and create predictive models to control the incidence of toxigenic fungi and mycotoxins12 and the delay of harvesting of oleaginous species, such as peanut may cause increase of A. flavus contamination of pods, production of aflatoxin G1 (AFG1 ), aflatoxins G2 (AFG2 ) and drying environment may cause higher incidence of A. flavus in the seeds.13

The aim of this research was study the mycobiota of crambe and the natural incidence of aflatoxins (AFs), ochratoxin A (OTA), fumonisin B1 (FB1 ) and zearalenone (ZEA) according to pre-harvest handling of grains.


Materials and Methods

Abstract | Keywords | Abbreviations | Introduction | Materials and Methods | Results | Discussion | Conclusion | Conflicts of Interest | References



The experiment was performed at the laboratories of the “Nucleus of mycological and mycotoxicological researches” (NĂșcleo de pesquisas micolĂłgicas e micotoxicolĂłgicas (NPMM)) of the Universidade Federal Rural do Rio de Janeiro (UFRRJ), Brazil. Crambe grains samples came from the experimental field (2 hectares) of the UFRRJ Department of fitotechnic of SeropĂ©dica City, State of Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. The samples used had been collected during harvests performed in 2012 and 2013. The samples from the 2012 harvest had grown in areas either with or without residuals of sunflower plants. The samples from the 2013 harvest had grown in areas with different potassium fertilization (0, 15, 30, 60 or 90 kg K2 O/he) and were harvested with different moistures: 45%, 18% or 9%. During the two harvests drying kept under field conditions, the grains were in uncontrolled environment for drying.

Determination of Water Activity

Grain samples were submitted to water activity (aw) measurement using AqualabŸ cx2 equipment (Decagon Devices Inc., USA).

Mycobiota Count, Isolation and Identification

Mycobiota analysis was performed by decimal dilution in plates, 0.1 ml of each dilution was inoculated in three different culture media: Dichloran Glycerol (DG18) agar for xerophylic fungi, Dichloran, Rose-Bengal Chloramphenicol (DRBC) agar for total fungi estimation14 and Nash-Snyder Agar (NSA) for isolation of Fusarium species.15 Plates were incubated at 25 ÂșC for seven days. Quantification was performed as CFUs per gram of sample (10 to 100 CFU/g). Some strains were selected for species identification. Species identification was realized according to macroscopic and microscopic features of samples and according to taxonomic tables.14-16 Direct plating of grains was also performed. Ten grains of crambe were disinfected and directly distributed on plates containing DRBC, DG18 or NSA agar media. Plates were incubated at 25 ÂșC for seven days. All plates were assessed and results were expressed as percentage of infected grains. Fungal samples isolated by this technique were classified according to the specific taxonomic keys, described above.

Mycotoxicologic Assessment

Detection and quantification of total AFs, OTA, FB1 and ZEA was performed with purification in specific VICAMŸ immunoaffinity columns. Duplicate analysis were performed according to the preconized procedures of any immunoaffinity column (Aflatest, Ocratest, Fumotest e Zeatest VicamÂź, Watertown, MA, USA) for HPLC analysis.17 After samples extraction, screening was performed in a 4ex series VICAMŸ fluorimeter and successive high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) analysis (LC 2000 JASCOŸ system equipped with fluorescence detector and C18 SUPELCOŸ silica column). Mobile phase A: water, mobile phase B: acetonitrile/water (95:5, v/v), the flow rate was 50 ÎŒL/min. The sample was reconstituted in 400 ÎŒL of the starting mobile phase, filtered and 20 ÎŒL were injected. External standards for comparison (OTA, FB1 , ZEA and AFs) were calibrated according to Association of Official Analytical Chemists (AOAC), to establishes the detection and quantification limits.

Statistical Analysis

Analysis of variance (ANOVA) was performed to analyze the data. Before performing ANOVA analysis, all data were transformed in Log 10(x+1). Duncan test was performed to compare fungal concentration in the different culture media. Least Significant Difference (LSD) Fisher test was chosen to compare mycotoxins quantification data. All statistical analysis were performed using SAS GLM procedure (PROC GLM) (SAS Institute, Cary, NC, USA).



Abstract | Keywords | Abbreviations | Introduction | Materials and Methods | Results | Discussion | Conclusion | Conflicts of Interest | References


A high variability and heterogeneity of the parameters along the year and moistures percent from studied samples was observed. The aW, temperatures and precipitation submitted to grains in the different handlings varied, as described: 0.909-0.592, 23.00 °C – 19.00 °C and 25.00-0.20 mm respectively (Table 1).

The mycological research determinate a fungal incidence, with a count in DRBC, DG18 and NSA media varied from 3.4×106 to 1.3×104 CFU.g-1 (Table 2) and the filamentous fungi were predominant over yeasts with an isolated frequency of 65 fungi strains belonging to genera Aspergillus, Fusarium, Penicillium, Cladosporium, Eurotium, Alternaria and Curvularia spp. (Table 3). CouldnÂŽt observes significant difference (p≄0.05) among plate counts of samples for the compared parameters (fertilization and residuals on the ground).

From these samples, were identified the main mycotoxins producing species: genus Aspergillus: A. flavus, A. parasiticus, A. oryzae, A. fumigatus, A. niger aggregated. From genus Penicillium were isolated the species: P. citrinum, P. clavatus and from genus Fusarium: F. verticillioides e F. chlmydosporum (Table 3).

Mycotoxins research presents the detected several mycotoxins in studied samples: AFB1 (39.00-4.23 ”g.Kg-1), OTA(4.60-4.01 mg.Kg-1) and ZEA(0.76-0.74 mg.Kg-1) (Table 4).


The precipitation along the years rising the humidity of the grains and aw may foster fungal contamination of grains, jeopardizing its use and processing.19,20 The evaluation of these parameters is a good reference for a predictive condition and modulations.21

Crambe grains obtained from plants grown in areas with residuals of sunflowers on the ground showed higher counts on DRBC medium compared to the values practiced by Good Manufacturing Practices (GMP)22 and Brazil. All samples showed higher concentration of fungi than prescribed by international recommendations and regulations. Grains from the third harvest showed higher fungal contamination, probably because of the heavier rainfall during the three days before the harvest (25 mm) as compared to the others (Table 1). The precipitation and harvest time modulate higher fungal counts.23

Observed higher count of fungi in DG18 medium in samples of crambe grains from areas with sun flower residual culture and from samples obtained from the second harvest (C2). The higher contamination with fungi in samples from the second harvest could be associated to the dry weather during the three days before harvesting (0.2 mm of rainfall) as compared to the other samplings.

The high concentration of fungi may affect the quality of feed, causing economic losses and damages to animal health. The importance of meteorological study during harvest to assess the risk of contamination by mycotoxins producing fungal species.24

Aflatoxins are produced by fungi of the Aspergillus flavus groups, such as Aspergillus flavus and A. parasiticus, common in grains and in areas with high air humidity.25 The most important abiotic factors which influence growth and AFs, OTA, FB1 and ZEA production by such spoilage fungi include water availability, temperature and when grain is moist.26

Calcination does not affect the population of Aspergillus spp. on the ground, and does not prevent the contamination of hulls and peanuts grains. Also describe, periods of lower humidity of the ground are associated to higher frequency of Aspergillus flavus isolation.27

Researches relative of different partitioning mycotoxins in fractions of cereals, when they are milled and used for different purposes, including human and animal consumption. The relevance of the mycotoxins founded are corresponding with European dates, as show a relevance of incidence of AFs, OTA, ZEA, DON and FB1 in grains.28

The relevance of weather forecast and climate knowledge during harvest and point out the importance of drawing sampling plans and predictive models to assess the risk of contamination by fungi in cultivated areas. The quality of crambe grains may be strongly affected by the exposition to variable environmental conditions. More studies are required on the quality of this feed and continuous analysis are necessary to protect the safety of crambe grains and improve its use for Brazilian herd.


In relation to the assessed parameters, considering the low toxin levels found and the use of available material for animal feed, the crambe proves to be a safe food to be exploited for animal nutrition. The high counts of fungi and the presence of detectable mycotoxins in the grains suggest critical situations at preharvest stage and needs to review and control this practice. The presence of fungi and mycotoxins in crambe grains associated to the exposure to adverse meteorological conditions may cause a risk of contamination to the animals that will feed on these grains.

Conflicts of interest

The authors declare that they have no conflicts of interest.